Wiki

AI 落地争论再起：是新一代 RPA 还是被高估的咨询外包？

2026-05-16 周六 (ET) · 主帖 8 / 回复 64
以下部分引用 AI 总结，现阶段 AI 仍然有幻觉。请以内容的原文为准。
一些重点
  1. AI 落地争论 AI 是否为 glorified Accenture，Ken Griffin 态度 180 度大转弯
  2. 半导体供应链MTK 估值偏紧，EMIB-T 崛起利好 ABF 载板，MOCVD 成光模块长瓶颈
  3. 13F 信号Tepper 减持中国，Drucker 交易频繁无信号，13F 价值在于基金 mandate
  4. 宏观资金流SPX 涨幅透支 AI 增量，外资流出亚洲科技，韩国散户接盘
  5. 市场八卦SA LP 办公室被 DOJ 包围传闻引发热议，最终确认为玩笑

1 AI 落地与商业化争论

AI 落地定性 ⟪LINK28⟫

AI 落地定性分歧：多头视其为新一代 RPA，空头认为仅是高级外包 Ken Griffin 态度反转成多头关键论据

  • 空方观点: AI 本质 = glorified Accenture，企业用新头衔包装传统外包工作。当前处于蜜月期，长期在资金、电力、物理层面不可持续[1]Randy Marsh · 05-16"That ai is basically a glorified accenture" [2]Randy Marsh · 05-16"In many ways. Money/economics is only one part of the issue. Power is another phase then there’s land & water. Then …"。
  • 多方反驳: AI = 企业生产力下一代 RPA/BPA。过去自动化瓶颈 = 确定性限制（难预见边缘情况） → 新 AI/Agentic workflows = 实现动态决策[3]Mo W · 05-16"Ah. No I don't think AI is the new Accenture. It’s clear that AI is the new rpa/bpa for enterprise productivity + itsm +…"。
  • Ken Griffin 反转: Citadel 的 Ken Griffin 态度 180 度大转弯：AI 工具链生产力在过去几个月发生阶跃变化，原本需数周的金融高技能工作现由 AI agent 在几小时内完成[4]Akh · 05-16"A big pivot from Citadel's Ken Griffin on AI: “Number one is, in the last few months, there has been a step change in th…"。
  • FDE 角色定位: 技术从业者反驳：FDE（Forward Deployed Engineer）= 90/00 年代的现场 IT 顾问，专注特定技术（如 Claude）以加快企业上市时间，不否定技术本身价值[5]overunderfit · 05-16"Seems like a clickbait title? FDE’s are just glorified on-site IT consultants from the 90s/2000s. They are experts at th…"。

2 半导体与硬件供应链

MTK 与先进封装 ⟪LINK29⟫

MTK 估值偏紧，EMIB-T 崛起重塑载板生态

  • MTK 估值分歧: MTK 近几个月上涨约 80%，未来 ASIC 订单已被定价。高盛 NT$5,000 目标价基于 4Q28 ASIC 营收达 US$20.5B 的激进假设；保守预测 2028 年 ASIC 营收约 US$24B，EPS 目标 NT$221.6，对应目标价约 NT$4,000[6]Terminal Junkie · 05-16"Random Thoughts: 1. *MediaTek upside is still there, but valuation is getting tight:* MTK has been up ~80% over the past…"。
  • TSMC 封装隐忧: Rubin Ultra 4 芯片版可能采用 Intel EMIB-T → 暗示 CoWoS 短期仍受制于扩展/翘曲限制，EMIB-T 成为更好近期方案，TSMC 下一个催化剂 = CoPoS[6]Terminal Junkie · 05-16"Random Thoughts: 1. *MediaTek upside is still there, but valuation is getting tight:* MTK has been up ~80% over the past…"。
  • ABF 载板利好: EMIB-T 扩展 → ABF 载板生态更关键（超高密度布线、精确桥接嵌入等），市场低估了大型封装带来的基板复杂性。Unimicron 被点名看好[6]Terminal Junkie · 05-16"Random Thoughts: 1. *MediaTek upside is still there, but valuation is getting tight:* MTK has been up ~80% over the past…" [7]Terminal Junkie · 05-17"<@U0AR4MMGK5E> i've been a big supporter of unimicron"。
  • 光模块瓶颈: 光模块瓶颈不仅是 InP，MOCVD 设备产能可能是更长期瓶颈。AIXTRON 和 VECO（将与 ACLS 合并）受关注[6]Terminal Junkie · 05-16"Random Thoughts: 1. *MediaTek upside is still there, but valuation is getting tight:* MTK has been up ~80% over the past…" [8]Cout47 · 05-16"Aixtron is a pure play and the US equivalent is VECO (and it’s gonna merge with ACLS in 2H26). They both look interestin…"。
  • PCB 设备: PCB 制造工具供应商（特别是钻孔机）受关注，如 Ta Liang、Shenzhen Han’s CNC Tech、Han’s Laser，以及日本 Union Tool（超精密 TSV 钻头全球领导者）[6]Terminal Junkie · 05-16"Random Thoughts: 1. *MediaTek upside is still there, but valuation is getting tight:* MTK has been up ~80% over the past…" [9]Cliff Ocean · 05-17"<@U0AQQ553F7T> You should look Union Tool in JPN re: point 6. Global leader in ULF coated drill bits for ultra precise t…"。

3 资金面与宏观

SA LP 调查传闻 ⟪LINK30⟫

SA LP 办公室被 DOJ 包围传闻发酵，最终被证实为玩笑

  • 传闻起因与证伪: 群内流传 SA LP 办公室被 DOJ 车辆包围，引发 13F 延迟提交猜测[10]Randy Marsh · 05-16"Hearing that SA LP office is surrounded by vehicles from DOJ. No idea what's happening." [11]Cout47 · 05-16"Maybe thats why the 13f is not filing…"。随后确认为无源头的玩笑，群友证实纯属虚构[12]Akh · 05-17"we've leaned b.s. Jukan" [13]KenteClarke · 05-17"This was a joke to be clear"。

13F 信号价值 ⟪LINK31⟫

13F 信号取决于基金 Mandate，短线基金无参考价值

  • Tepper 减持中国: Appaloosa 13F 显示 Q1 唯一新建仓是 SNDK，同时缓慢放弃中国头寸[14]H-Cap · 05-16"David Tepper’s Appaloosa Management disclosed in an SEC filing its holdings as of March 31, 2026. Appaloosa’s one new bu…" [15]BTJ · 05-17"Many people disparage looking at 13Fs due to the lag but I do think there is value to it based on the Fund. Looking at T…"。
  • 信号有效性: 对 Tepper 或 Druckenmiller 等频繁转向基金，13F 无法预测当前仓位；仅对长线持有基金（如 Hohn），13F 才有信号价值[15]BTJ · 05-17"Many people disparage looking at 13Fs due to the lag but I do think there is value to it based on the Fund. Looking at T…" [16]James · 05-17"The only signal in 13fs is the fund mandate. If you're looking at Hohn or some other long duration hold group, there's s…"。

宏观与资金流向 ⟪LINK32⟫

SPX 涨幅透支 AI 价值，外资流出亚洲科技

  • AI 价值透支: AI 效率提升预计创造 $5-20trn 现值，但自 ChatGPT 推出以来 SPX 已上涨 $30trn[17]H-Cap · 05-17"We all get the AI efficiency boost. Our earlier work points to $5-20trn worth of value creation in present value terms. …"。
  • 外资流出: 本周外资（FIIs）从除中国外的 EM 亚洲净流出 $17bn，其中韩国流出 $13bn，被散户 $14bn 买入抵消[18]H-Cap · 05-17"US visit to Beijing felt like largely non-event though latest headlines suggest both nations could look to reduce trade …"。